Financial Intelligence is part of the Informa Intelligence Division of Informa PLC
This is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.
Growth vs Value in 2Q21: Chasing under-performance?
Tech is back! After five months of some ups and more downs, the month of June has been kind to the technology sector. From the mid-May low, the NASDAQ has outperformed the S&P 500 by almost 7%.
If we look in smart beta terms, Growth has outperformed Value by around 11.5% over the same period.
A quick look at EPFR’s Fund Flow Data, however, shows that investors have been slow – or unwilling – to get this message. Going into the final week of the second quarter, funds managed for value had attracted more money, or seen less redeemed, than their growth counterparts in nine of the past 10 weeks. But growth funds had collectively outperformed value funds five of the past six weeks.
A key question for the second half of 2021 is whether investors are (a) reading the tea leaves correctly when they drag their feet or (b) missing the start of a new and lasting trend. Should they be switching back into technology and other growth stocks?
Polishing up the right crystal ball
Quantitative Insight (Qi) first introduced its proprietary version of Principal Component Analysis in March’s blog, “Inflation, Real Yields & the Million Dollar Question”. That blog started provided an initial look at Qi’s methodology with a particular focus on financial assets’ sensitivity to macro factors – specifically equity markets and their sensitivity to inflation and real yields.
Another output from Qi’s models is a valuation measure. By identifying the independent impact of various macro factors like economic growth, inflation, financial conditions and risk appetite on an asset, Qi can roll that up into an aggregate macro-warranted model value. For example, some of the factors used to evaluate US equities include:
In practice, Qi isolates macro factors in turn, shifting each one higher by one daily standard deviation. Given the weight on that factor within each principal component (PC) -- and given the regression beta estimates -- shifting the factor will have some impact on the asset’s valuation.
These independent betas show individual factor sensitivity, as we explained in the March blog, but can also be aggregated together to provide a macro model value. The gap between that value and the asset’s spot price is Qi’s Fair Value Gap (FVG).
Fair value or fair growth?
For discretionary investors, who face a relative dearth of quantitative macro signals, the FVG offers a potential trade idea.
When it comes to allocations between growth and value plays, what is the FVG process signaling?
Below (see Chart 1) we show the NASDAQ vs S&P 500 model from the Qi portal. Macro fair value for that relative value pair on July 7 was $3.33. The R-Squared of that model is 67%, which means that currently Qi’s macro factors can explain 67% of the variance in that ratio, and the difference between spot (the white line) and model values (red line) is 1 sigma which is 2.2% in absolute terms.
Chart 1
The next chart shows the history of that Fair Value Gap over the past year. Relative to the macro environment, the NASDAQ is close to its richest levels to the S&P 500 as we have seen in the last 12 months.
Chart 2
Taking the smart beta approach, we can use Vanguard-tracking ETFs – VTV (Value) versus VUG (Growth) – and we end up with the same general picture.
Chart 3
Unsurprisingly the profile looks the same – value has underperformed of late and now sits 1.0 sigma (4.5%) cheap to growth.
Painting the trade alpha
The model is delivering a clear signal, whether applied to the index space or to smart beta vehicles. But maximizing its value to portfolio managers generally requires additional layers of analysis.
A key issue is the reversion of the FVG towards zero. Is the gap closing due to movements in the spot price of the asset, or changes in the factors driving the model? The answer has very different profit and loss implications.
In the case of US equities, the biggest single driver of the VTV/VUG ratio currently is the expectations surrounding monetary policy and the timing of any shift by the Federal Reserve to a tightening bias. This factor alone accounts for around a third of model’s explanatory power (see Chart 4 below).
Chart 4
The tech sector is especially reliant on ongoing quantitative easing, a relationship Qi first flagged early in February, and the taper (or data) tantrum of Q1 proved particularly painful for technology stocks.
An understanding of what is driving any asset price is a key part of any investment process. The Qi framework provides an empirical answer so that a discretionary oversight can be added to the initial trade idea.
In this instance, a Growth bull can override the FVG signal providing they have confidence the Fed will prevent another bout of bond volatility / bear steepening of the US yield curve. Conversely, equity PMs with a bearish tilt on the bond market, have ammunition (both from valuations & critical macro relationships) to fade the recent tech outperformance.
At its simplest every quant, portfolio manager and trader is essentially trying to forecast a future price. Aligning macro factor sensitivities with valuation gaps helps provide helps investment professionals do exactly that.
Get Quants Corner delivered straight to your inbox! Subscribe here.
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 27 May 2022
Although the flow of unsettling developments continued in late May – will Covid-19 pass the baton to Monkeypox? – investors recovered some of their appetite for exposure to US assets.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Vik Srimurthy 25 May 2022
MSCI developed the classification of country equity stock markets based not only on how advanced, economically, the country is, but also how easy it is for global investors to access its domestic stock market.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 20 May 2022
EPFR-tracked Equity Funds extended their longest run of outflows since 3Q19 during the week ending May 18 as slowing global growth, tighter monetary policy in the US, war in Ukraine and widespread lockdowns in China kept investors on the defensive.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 17 May 2022
Asset markets endured further pain during the second week of May as investors tried – and largely failed -- to square tighter monetary policy in the US and other markets with the latest global GDP forecasts.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 06 May 2022
The first week of May ended with the US Federal Reserve raising its key interest rate by 50 basis points. Investors, who expected a hike of that magnitude but feared the Fed might opt for a 0.75% increase, spent most of the week taking defensive positions.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 02 May 2022
As key US indexes closed their books on a month that saw the Nasdaq record its biggest drop since October 2008, investors seeking to escape market volatility turned to cash and to Chinese equity.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 22 Apr 2022
With the opening weeks of the 1Q22 corporate earnings season raising more questions than it answers, US mortgage rates continuing to climb, global growth forecasts being trimmed and Russia’s invasion of Ukraine now in its third month, investors found a lot to like about the sidelines during the third week of April.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Vik Srimurthy 21 Apr 2022
Balanced Funds, also known as hybrid or multi-asset funds, are a class of funds that contain both a debt and equity within a single portfolio.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 15 Apr 2022
Investors surveying the investment landscape during the second week of April saw more thistles and dandelions than daffodils.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 08 Apr 2022
Hopes for an early resolution of the Russian invasion of Ukraine took a hit during the first week of 2Q22 as evidence of Russian war crimes came to light. So did hopes for a measured pace to US interest rate hikes after US Federal Reserve Vice Chair Lael Brainard stated that the Fed needs to pick up the pace of its monetary tightening.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 07 Apr 2022
Healthcare has long been one of the core defensive sectors. In recent years, however, a sub-group of the healthcare universe – biotechnology – has claimed a growing share of the interest in, and flows to, EPFR-tracked Healthcare Sector Funds.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 07 Apr 2022
Increased, and more efficient, production is one of the major keys to non-inflationary economic growth. Deploying capital goods, technology and improved computing speed should translate into higher production and greater productivity.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 07 Apr 2022
Historically, rotating between sectors meant shifting between well established groupings such as real estate, financials and utilities. Increased computing power and access to new datasets are changing this dynamic. Investors and managers can now rotate within sectors and even geographic or thematic sub-groups of that sector.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Vik Srimurthy 06 Apr 2022
I have always been at a loss to understand why the phrase “old wine in new bottles” is pejorative.
Topic Industry News
EPFR - fund flow & allocations data
By Cameron Brandt 01 Apr 2022
The final week of March saw Russia’s invasion of Ukraine head into its sixth week. But investors appear increasingly comfortable with the idea that it is predominantly a European problem, that its short-term impact on energy prices will be blunted by higher production outside Russia and the end of winter in the northern hemisphere, and that the stalling of Russia’s advance makes a settlement of the conflict increasingly likely.
Topic Industry News
Would you like to request sample data or analysis from Informa Financial Intelligence?