skip to main content
Close Icon We use cookies to improve your website experience.  To learn about our use of cookies and how you can manage your cookie settings, please see our Cookie Policy.  By continuing to use the website, you consent to our use of cookies.
Global Search Configuration

In the aftermath of the Credit Crisis, diversification has come under the microscope. Portfolios that were traditionally considered diversified could not withstand the global reach of the crisis and protections failed when they were needed most. The past decade has proven that simply adding foreign investments to a portfolio does not equal diversification.

 

Below we take a deeper look at diversification and the different alternative investments available to retail investors to determine the effect they have on a portfolio and whether they are doing their intended job or not.

 

Before we get started it’s important to disclose the asset classes and corresponding indexes used to run the mean variance optimization analysis. Table 1 displays the basic asset classes, in addition to the three alternative assets used – real estate investment trusts (REITs), commodities, and long/short funds.

 


 Table 1

The process for constructing a risk/return optimized portfolio begins with creating a mix of investments with low correlations.  Since investors are risk averse, it’s important to realize that correlations often fluctuate during a market cycle, and particularly increase during a crisis compared to long term averages. Figure 1 shows the correlations between different asset classes from January 1997 to September 2016, which are noticeably lower than the correlations for the same asset classes during the credit crisis (Figure 2).


 Figure 1

 


 Figure 2

 

The above correlation matrices provide insight into why a diversified portfolio based on historical standards fell prey to the Credit Crisis and why it’s imperative to broaden your use of alternatives when looking for enhanced diversification.

 

In addition to knowing how the different asset classes correlate to one another, it’s equally important to understand where the risk in the portfolio is coming from so you know the type of hedging strategy needed. As shown in figure 3, a typical 60/40 portfolio is nearly perfectly correlated to an all equity portfolio, while this same 60/40 portfolio has very low correlation to interest rate movements (10 yr. Treasury) and is negatively correlated to changes in inflation (CPI).


 Figure 3 – 60% S&P 500 / 40% Barclays U.S. Aggregate portfolio is rebalanced  annually.

 

With the above knowledge in hand, we can move forward with constructing an efficient frontier to determine the effect alternatives have on a traditional asset allocation consisting of basic asset classes. To determine the forecasted returns for the core asset classes, we use the Black Litterman forecasting model, whereas for the alternative asset classes we use the historical returns (Jan 1997 – Sept 2016).

 

As you can see in figure 4, by adding the three alternatives listed above to an allocation case which includes the basic assets, the efficient frontier shifts to the northwest, which represents higher returns and lower risk. This is the intended result of adding alternatives to an allocation.

 


 Figure 4 – Past performance is no guarantee of future results.  For illustrative  purposes only.

Figure 4 also displays hypothetical portfolios, composed of the basic assets (blue font) as well as portfolios including alternatives (olive font). Table 2 below provides the details of each portfolio.  Focusing on hedging against equity risk, we added a 15 percent allocation to alternatives, split evenly across the three alternative investments, while reducing the equity allocations of each portfolio. As expected, adding alternatives increases diversification by reducing the expected risk, however, adding alternatives results in lower expected returns for each portfolio.


 Table 2 - – Past performance is no guarantee of future results.  For illustrative      purposes only.

Taking this a step further, we can look at the individual alternative investments to determine if they are adding value to the portfolios. As you can see in figure 5, the commodity asset has a very low forecasted return while its risk is in line with U.S. equities. By removing the five percent commodity allocation from the portfolios, the return/risk characteristics for the portfolios become more attractive (see table 3).

 


 Figure 5 – Past performance is no guarantee of future results.  For illustrative  purposes only.


 Table 3 – Past performance is no guarantee of future results.  For illustrative purposes  only.

When creating a portfolio for your client which aims to reduce unsystematic risk via diversification, alternative investments need to be considered. Keep in mind that not all alternative investments are created equally, and that each alternative provides unique benefits to a portfolio. It’s important to look at all factors including what risk(s) you are trying to protect against as well as how correlations fluctuate during different market cycles. 

Recommended Articles

  • Zephyr Portfolio Analytics

    Ryan Nauman's Weekly Recap: COVID-19 Market Edition 08.03.20

    By Ryan Nauman 04 Aug 2020

    The week ahead is another busy week for earnings releases. The week may not have as many blue-chip names as this week, but it does include companies that were hindered by the economic shutdown like Walt Disney, Wynn Resorts, and TripAdvisor. On the flip side, the week includes some companies who may have benefited from the shelter-in-place trade such as Square, Roku and Clorox. As for economic releases, the headliner will be Friday’s jobs report. After the initial spike in unemployment, the labor market rebounded the past two months. However, the number of new coronavirus cases has been on the rise and resulted in some new restrictions on businesses, which may again adversely affect employment numbers. Ryan Nauman's Weekly Recap: COVID-19 Market Edition and subscribe to have it delivered to your inbox each week!

    Topics Industry News

  • Zephyr Portfolio Analytics

    Zephyr Platform Case Study: Thrivent

    03 Aug 2020

    Thrivent has been a client since 2020 and subscribes to the Zephyr platform. Matthew Mast, FIC, MBA is a Financial Professional for Thrivent and is responsible for due diligence on model portfolios, creating current versus proposed client portfolios to show clients where Thrivent can add value, and preparing materials for client meetings. Mr. Mast first experienced Zephyr at a previous firm. A Senior Advisor colleague used it extensively and, “loved it.” When Mr. Mast moved to take a leadership role at Thrivent, he knew Zephyr would be a valuable addition to support their in‐depth due diligence process and their communication with clients. “The functionality and presentation of Zephyr are fantastic. We like that you can create blends, measure them, and put together a very nice-looking, custom presentation that packages our thinking and really shows the value we bring our clients.” Read more...

    Topics Industry News Manager Analysis

  • Zephyr Portfolio Analytics

    Ryan Nauman's Weekly Recap: COVID-19 Market Edition 07.27.20

    By Ryan Nauman 27 Jul 2020

    The week ahead is one of the busiest weeks of the Q2 earnings season which includes some of the largest and most popular traded companies. The releases that I am particularly intrigued by are Apple, Amazon.com, Alphabet and Caterpillar. As for economic data, the first iteration of second quarter GDP will be released, which is expected to show the worst contraction in economic growth since the Great Financial Crisis. The additional item I will be closely watching and listening to will be the FOMC meeting announcement and Chairman Powell’s follow-up press conference. Very few expect the FOMC to make adjustments to its monetary policies, however, their comments about the future path of their policies, the health of the U.S. economy, and the end of the CARES Act will be closely watched. Ryan Nauman's Weekly Recap: COVID-19 Market Edition and subscribe to have it delivered to your inbox each week!

    Topics Industry News

;

Any questions? Speak to a specialist

Would you like to request sample data or analysis from Informa Financial Intelligence? 

See how our tailored solutions can help you gain a competitive advantage: